Leave a comment

Lessons from the Aether: Law & Order and Why Following a Formula Is Not a Bad Thing

Tweet of the Day: Writing Excuses 8.2: Hero’s Journey 


To call something “formulaic” is to hang a sign that says things like: unimaginative, repetitive, and dull among other things. Yet Hollywood thrives on formulas, as does many literary genres. Take the show Law & Order as an example. It spawn at least five spin offs (all of them off the air except L&O UK). The original lasted twenty seasons. That’s right from 1990 to 2010. According to Wikipedia:

At the time of its cancellation, Law & Order was the longest-running crime drama on American primetime television. After The Simpsons, both Law & Order and Gunsmoke tied for the second longest-running scripted American primetime series with ongoing characters.

Each episode followed the same pattern:

  1. Act 1: Investigation of the crime. The detectives come to the crime scene, somebody makes a quip about the death/dead, followed by an investigation with at least one red herring and the arrest of the subject.
  2. Act 2: Prosecutors try to “nail the bastard” and go back and forth with the defense.
  3. Act 3: The verdict. Either someone confesses on the stand or the verdict comes in. Most of the time guilty, but not always.

Along the way the show stayed topical by dealing with media, gun violence, national politics, immigration, sex, and anything else the producers could “rip from the headlines”. After 20 years the show runners tried to sprinkle a few wrinkles here and there but most of the time the stuck to the   inevitable conclusion, that is, if it was a tough case, they would lose, an easy case, a win but with some troubling after thoughts. The shows main innovation is that it linked to types of shows: the police procedural and the courtroom drama. It broke with the assumption (although Criminal Intent played it straight) that once the police got their man, the case was close. Instead it showed that police make mistakes and that prosecutors, regardless of how well meaning they are can still screw up royally.

The formula worked even after multiple shows went through multiple cast changes. However even formulas wear thin, as the cancellation of most of the franchise has shown. Without good characters (and good actors) to heft the burden, the show formula started to show its weaknesses and fell apart in the long run.

But what a run.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: